SEXUAL ETHICS
This came from the past, like many of my pieces since having a stroke last July. My typing is improving, though unlikely to get back to 50 words per minute of accurate typing as it was. My brain is mostly working, though forgetful - I think and hope that's due to the stress of the slow recovery, and will soon be restored. So there's a good possibility of more original stuff. Meanwhile, following Gerard Siero's suggestion that I say something about justice, here is this.
It was composed in a hurry during a Synod debate in 1991, and delivered as a speech. The editor of a collection of papers on sexual ethics, which were the subject of the debate as they were to be published in the Synod's name, asked me to turn it into a paper for inclusion as a Preface to the collection, and this is what I submitted. It by no means addresses all the issues, but intends to provide a Biblical framework for considering the issues - the big picture, so to speak.
The context of the debate and the booklet was differing attitudes to sexuality in the Anglican Church, and was triggered by the appointment of a Chaplain to the sex industry in Canberra. The Reverend Bill Huff-Johnson was the Chaplain and he did his job well, but not according to some Synod members who thought he should be insisting that the sex workers should "sin no more," and get out of the business. I had this in mind in formulating my speech, and therefore this article.
What is good?
Peter Llewellyn
This was written as a Preface to a small book comprising several papers on sexual ethics produced for the Synod of the Anglican Diocese of Canberra & Goulburn. It is published in that book under my former name, Peter Mendham, when I was Academic Dean at St Mark’s National Theological Centre, Canberra. It is based on a speech I made at the 1991 session of the Synod, during the debate on the reception of an earlier version of these papers.
He has told you, O mortal, what is good;
and what does the Lord require of you
but to do justice, and to love kindness,
and to walk humbly with your God?
—Micah 6:8, NRSV
Right behaviour for most Christians is governed by principles derived, at least in part, from the teachings of the Bible. For many of their decisions, however, people find it easier to apply rules than to work out how these complex principles are to be used in practice. The Bible contains both foundational principles as well as specific sayings which can be taken to provide the rules people want.
It is always difficult to sort all this biblical material out. Some parts of it seem to be in conflict with other parts; for many people, it is just too confusing. In this short paper, therefore, I want to explain how the Bible approaches ethics in general, and the ethics of sexuality in particular.
In the Bible there are three different, though related, approaches to ethics, each of which has a bearing on how we respond to the ethics of sexuality.
The ethic of justice. From the first part of Micah 6:8, the Lord requires us ‘to do justly’. This is the foundational principle which lay at the heart of the message of the prophets: God’s rebuke of his people was, more than anything else, that they failed to deal fairly with one another, especially with the poor and oppressed. This principle results in rules such as those found in Luke 3:10-14, where the crowds are instructed to share their possessions, tax-collectors to collect only what is due and soldiers to refrain from extortion and to be satisfied with their wages.
The ethic of compassion. The Lord requires us ‘to love kindness’. The Hebrew word hesed, translated above as ‘kindness’, is also rendered by ‘loyalty’, ‘mercy’, ‘steadfast love’ and ‘compassion’. It is a very rich concept, and like justice, very important to the Hebrew prophets. It is interesting that its most common use by far is for ‘the mercy (or mercies) of the Lord’, especially in the Psalms. Similar ideas, notably compassion for the multitude, are used of Jesus in the gospels. It is no exaggeration to say that, in both Old and New Testaments, mercy is the most important characteristic of God. As a principle of behaviour for human beings, then, the ethic of compassion is based on imitating the nature of God.
The ethic of holiness. The third ethic of the Bible is the principle of purity, or holiness. A very large proportion of Old Testament law (Torah), especially in the book of Leviticus, is devoted to aspects of ritual purity, from circumcision to laws for distinguishing what is clean from what is unclean. These laws are not very much concerned with morality – a ‘clean’ object or creature is not better than an ‘unclean’ one – but with how the people might respond to the holiness of God. The foundational principle is that the people of God are to be holy, as the Lord is holy: ‘to walk humbly with your God’. This has some obvious moral implications, but we must be careful not to read more into it than is actually there. Christians sometimes tend to think of ‘holiness’ as mainly a moral idea; it is not. Nevertheless it is a vital ethical principle of the highest importance: it is what distinguishes Judeo-Christian ethics from secular worldviews. At its base, it is the ethic of relationship with God; for purity and holiness are understood in the Bible as means to the end of knowing God, which is in turn defined as ‘eternal life’ (John 17:3).
Each of these three ethics forms a more or less independent system which may be used to direct and govern our behaviour. They are not entirely independent: the Sabbath laws, for example, have a justice and compassion element behind them as well as the primary purity motivation. But for purposes of clarity, we may regard them as if they were more completely independent than they are.
We might illustrate them by describing a caricature of what happens when each one is taken to extremes:
• The justice ethic taken alone leads to a passionate commitment to fairness for all – but at the same time produces a rigid refusal to make allowances for error or human weakness; an attractive fighter for human rights can also show up as an intolerant legalist.
• The compassion ethic taken alone shows a similar passion for the needs of the poor and oppressed, but without the ethic of justice shows the opposite tendency towards excessive tolerance; ‘sugary’ and ‘spineless’ are common adjectives used to describe this approach to ethics.
• The purity ethic taken alone leads to an excessive concern for one’s own standards: the refusal to allow Jesus to heal on the Sabbath is the classic example. There is likewise an unwillingness to take risks with one’s own purity for the sake of any other principle. This zeal for holiness is regularly caricatured in literature and the media as typical of religious people; Christians are often bewildered by this reaction, as they know their fellow-Christians to be people of deep compassion and concern for justice. It is hard for the church to throw the ‘holier than thou’ image.
It is evident that none of these systems is alone sufficient to provide a sound foundation for our ethics. We need to incorporate them all: to do justly, to love kindness, and to walk humbly with our God. But we need to know that there are situations where these three foundational principles come into a certain degree of conflict with each other, so that achieving a proper balance and priority is required.
How do we determine which principle is to take priority in any given situation? Jesus gives us the answer, at least in relation to conflict between the purity and justice ethics, in Luke 13:16: ‘And ought not this woman, a daughter of Abraham whom Satan bound for eighteen long years, be set free from this bondage on the Sabbath day?’ The purity laws come a distant last when human need is involved.
This gives us the clue in developing a biblical ethic of sexuality. Many of the regulatory purity laws deal with issues in sexual relationships – such as restrictions on permissible partners (Leviticus 18:6-18) and prohibitions of certain kinds of sexual activity (Leviticus 18:19-23). While Christians have tended to see these as moral issues, for Jewish interpreters they have been more correctly understood as issues of cleanness and uncleanness. On the other hand, the seventh commandment of the decalogue, ‘you shall not commit adultery’ (Exodus 20:14), implies a moral response – faithfulness – to the faithfulness of God to his people, as expressed in the prologue to the ten commandments: ‘I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of slavery’ (Exodus 20:2).
Over the centuries, both Jewish and Christian sexual ethics have been largely grounded in the ethic of purity. Questions of uncleanness have dominated the treatment of women in society and in the church, and the well-known tendency to make sexual matters taboo (in many societies, not only in Christian and Jewish societies) may be attributed to a fear of impurity. This had an unintended consequence: in societies where the ethic of purity is overthrown for some reason, it has not been replaced by any other ethic in the areas where it has had exclusive application. In other words, the departure of the ethic of purity has left a values vacuum – and this in turn has led worried Christians and some other concerned people to push for a return to the old ethic of purity. There’s a good case for that. There is, however, a better way.
Sexual ethics is in this like any other area of ethics: purity and holiness are good, justice is good, compassion is good; when deciding between different principles of goodness, we must be guided by what is the best or highest good. As purity is overruled by justice, so justice is very often tempered by mercy and compassion. This form of words, of justice being ‘tempered’ by mercy, shows that we do not feel comfortable with the idea of justice being overruled, even by mercy. That would suggest a degree of injustice, and we have a deep-rooted fear of a mercy that were to go as far as to be unjust – we feel that such a level of ‘mercy’ would not really be mercy at all, but moral weakness.
How does mercy temper justice, and justice overrule purity, in the case of sexual ethics? Let us examine briefly the two cases most discussed in this collection of papers, prostitution and homosexuality. The ethics of purity, at least at first sight, condemn outright both of these kinds of sexual expression. (In fact, I would argue, were there space, for a different consideration of each of these, but that would divert attention from the central question here.)
The ethics of justice require that sex workers, like all others in the community, be granted decent working conditions and protection from exploitation. They similarly require that gay men and lesbians be free from discriminatory policies and practices. These considerations outweigh any unequal treatment that may or may not be justified on an ethic of purity.
The ethics of compassion go further. They require that pastoral care be given to, not withheld from people involved in sexual activities of which we may well disapprove. Jesus’ famous encounter with the woman taken in adultery is a case in point. His final remark, ‘Go, and sin no more,’ must be put in the context of the previous sentence, ‘Neither do I condemn you’. Commentators often suggest that the woman can be treated in one way, and her sin in another; but it is not so easy, and Jesus does not do that. His response is thoroughly pastoral, leaving open the possibility for her of further ministry. So we, the church, must offer pastoral care to people of all kinds – of all sexual kinds – without the hidden implication of condemnation and exclusion.
May I suggest that the ethics of Jesus always gave first place to the principle of compassion, second to the demands of justice, without neglecting the ideals of purity and holiness. The great value to the church of the approach mostly taken in these papers is that the same ethical order is applied: from this we can learn to value people and to minister to them as they are, to work for the lifting of oppression and exploitation, and to lead men and women through a deeper holiness into that humble walk with God that is eternal life.

No comments:
Post a Comment