Monday, September 17, 2018

A WHITE MAN BEGINS TO DREAM

I got no dreaming, but often I have wished for it.[1]My grandfather said there was Aboriginal ancestry in our family; but he was a writer of sixpenny novels and some non-fiction that was about as fictional as they. Although he declared his commitment to truth in advertising, and failed as a newspaper editor because of it, we could never tell whether any of his oral stories were true. For about five minutes I believed his story of the bunyip that came up from the dam my cousins and I used to shoot air-rifles into, making a horrible gurgling noise as it approached the house – I was compelled, by weight of numbers of children and my being the eldest, to sleep on the verandah and the door was locked, as I discovered when the gurgling began around midnight. Over breakfast I asked, as casually as I could but not enough, what made that gurgling noise in the night. (It was, as he eventually told me, a Brush-tailed possum. The gurgling is still creepy.) Grandpa notwithstanding, I don’t think there’s much Aboriginality in my family.
On the too few occasions I’ve been permitted to sit with Aboriginal people in their own places – not in the sacred places, because they had been moved on from those – I have longed for the connections, the awareness of community, the inextricable link with the place and the earth and the creatures, and above all the one Creature whose Dreaming the people of that place share, different Creatures in different places. 
In my case there is no difficulty identifying the one Creature whose Dreaming I have a sense of sharing, in my own very limited way. That Creature is the White-bellied Sea-eagle, Haliaeetus leucogaster, and while these wonderful birds, described in field guides as “like a gigantic butterfly in flight,” are found all over South-East Asia, and around the whole coastline and many inland waters of Australia, their Home Camp, Munyunga waraga dhugan[2]in the language of the Yuin people of the New South Wales south coast from Jervis Bay to far east Gippsland, is where my spirit lives.
Every time I go on retreat, no matter whether it is in a coastal place where one might be blessed with a sight of the mighty Sea-eagle, or in the desert far out of her range at Koora Wilderness Retreat where I am now, I feel the call of the Sea-eagle. When I lived for a time on the south coast, first at Dignams Creek between Tilba and Cobargo, then further north at Tuross Head, I met with the Eagles many times, sometimes with a powerful numinous element. It was a vulnerable time for me; in 1996 I had, after a few false starts, crashed out of the Anglican ministry and the rest of my life with a major stress disorder and inexcusably bad behaviour, described as work-related stress, but there were many factors that even now, more than twenty years later, I cannot pin down. For some reason over that three years out I became sensitive to new forms of energy – new to me, anyway – such as earth energies and fault lines, sensing and even a couple of times seeing critters that I can only call “nature spirits,” Guardians of certain special places; and gaining connections to living creatures that went beyond admiration, to a level of intimacy with them, a phenomenon that for me has no adequate words.
This morning I twice walked the Koora labyrinth. It is a full-sized eleven-ring construction on the hard, sandy earth, marked out with small stones and a teapot, partly shaded by a magnificent Moreton Bay fig tree, which almost certainly doesn’t belong there, except that now it does, because of its relationship to the labyrinth. The thing about these human constructions on the surface of the earth is that while they are thoroughly mathematical, meticulously planned out, they sit so lightly. Their roots go down way beyond the roots we human visitors can dig, because they touch something that is already there, something in the dirt and the little plants and the rocks and the detritus that comes together as a powerful whole. Walking it is hard going, at least it is for me. The first time I was deliberately walking slowly, each step measured, not as deliberately slow as some of my friends walked it the last time I was here, but slow enough to feel that I was wading through mud on the dry ground, and I stopped at the turning points and felt the powerful rhythm of the tentative approach to the Centre, then turning away, whether in fear or shyness or just a general sense of not being ready, and then as I reached the long curved stretches in semi-circles that awareness of being kept at a distance, and of being compelled to walk where the path leads and not where the body wanted to go, and reaching another place of repentance – everywhere in the labyrinth is the presence of the Hebrew verb shub, which in its various forms means “turn,” “return,” “repent,” “turn away,” “turn back,” as you learn when you study the multifarious usage of this multivalent word in the Book of Jeremiah. “Why are my people turning away, turning in perpetual turning?”
After quite a long time of this – always it seems that the south-east quadrant is the quickest, and then the south west where you start and finish, and the other two on the north side are slower and more measured, even though they are all the same length – you get to the Centre, and cannot but stop. Eventually the labyrinth begins to kick you out, and you start again. Walking out on that first time I was agitated and struggling, spiritually finding it hard to breathe, and I stopped on the park bench thoughtfully provided by Anna and Pete in the shade of the great fig, and meditated, if that’s the word for what I was compelled to do, for quite a long time. I have never had to work so hard at a retreat.
I have not seen my friend and sometime mentor Father Eugene Stockton since 1979, when I walked away from the community he led in Manly in Sydney, to be ordained in Canberra. Eugene is a Catholic priest, the first of those beautiful post-Vatican II reconstructed priests that I have been privileged to get to know. In August 1975 I was given permission – for a while, the only non-Catholic to have this – to join the Manly Praise Community, a group of 15-20 spiritually-minded Catholic men and women who had been drawn into the rising Charismatic Renewal in their church. They used to meet in the Vestry of St Mary Immaculate Church in Manly, with the somewhat reluctant permission of the Parish Priest, and Fr Eugene was their leader and spiritual director. He was Lecturer in Sacred Theology at St Patrick’s Seminary up the top of the North Head hill, a wonderful place that is now an international hotel, and two of the Seminarians, Gerry and Wim (I was invited to attend and participate in a small way in their Ordination as Priests in St Mary’s Cathedral), were the musicians and worship leaders. These were glorious times, and they fed me as my own church did not. After some months, and there were in the meantime some good stories of how those very solid Catholics were persuaded to accept an ignorant, naïve Anglican into their midst, other Protestants came along, and soon, with the strong encouragement of Fr Eugene, the whole group – by then more than a hundred each week – came to do their thing in the premises of the Middle Earth Christian Resource Centre, where on a Friday night the sounds of prayer and praise and prophecy – and especially the sound of old George praying aloud, he having been taught to read and write by one of the Anglicans in the group, and having been supplied with a job mowing lawns by several others, and having self-respect for the first time in his life he learned to pray aloud, very loud, and loved it – rang down to Manly Beach at the end of the street.
As well as Priest and Lecturer, Fr Eugene was and still is an archeologist with a particular interest in Aboriginal sites in the Blue Mountains west of Sydney. It was his book The Aboriginal Gift[3]that I had with me after walking the labyrinth, and as I read bits of it the deep spiritual longing for a Dreaming of my own began to take over. After sitting, dozing, meditating and getting angry on behalf of a few people who have been mistreated by the Church, I got up and walked the endless interspiralled path a second time, this time much faster, purposeful, not to race nor to time the walk but to push the energy out. Something was about to break and I had to give it a chance.
The bird song never really ceases at Koora, and also there are plenty of human sounds, talking and machinery and traffic hurrying to Kalgoorlie and Sydney if you choose to hear. Out there on the labyrinth the human sounds were distant enough, and I could discern at least six species of birdsong, though almost none were visible. Last night around the campfire we heard a Spotted nightjar’s repetitive call, with its timid hooting followed by half a dozen quick notes, and again after a couple of seconds. It isn’t creepy like the Brush-tailed possum, but some people might be spooked. As I walked, the sky was utterly blue, empty of cloud, the temperature rising from freezing to a promised 26, flies everywhere and intensely gathering on my fly veil around my hat. The birds called louder than the flies buzzed. Oddly I found myself listening for the call of a raptor, any raptor though there were none, knowing that my White-bellied sea-eagle was not going to be there, and thought of the times they have come to me.
There was a special time in 1997, down on the New South Wales south coast. Many of the beaches from Merimbula up to Bermagui have a narrow stretch of heavily wooded scrub on the sandhills, then a long narrow lagoon running parallel to the beach, where ocean fish sometimes get captured after the extra high tides and become easy pickings for smart fishermen and Sea-eagles. The furthest north is just north of Bermi, and it might be the narrowest of them all. I stopped at the point just south of the end of the lagoon, where you can get across to the rocks beside the beach. There’s a single windswept tree on the ridge, and sitting in it this day were a pair of Sea-eagles, a couple, the much larger female above and the male lower in the tree, as is their custom. I went to within about five metres of these magnificent birds and talked with them. They told me that they were glad to see me – and that is why they stayed in the tree, did not fly away as is also their custom. Another afternoon they performed the mating ritual, the flyover with the locking of talons as they fell, joined, and broke apart to soar up again before they hit the ground. I watched spellbound for half an hour, was late for something, and didn’t care.
Some Aboriginal tribal groups like the word “totem,” used to describe their own special Creature. Other groups say it is unhelpful, an inappropriate word for their relationship with the Creature.[4]The preferred word is “Dreaming” – for that too is a word with much more nuanced meaning than in ordinary English usage.[5]The Dreaming is the timeless, eternal relationship of the tribal group, the moiety, with their land and the special Creature that lives there. The Creature, of course, can live wherever it finds a home, and that neither extends the Dreaming relationship to other places nor invalidates what is going on. It’s about the whole, the universe and the specific place all at once, and each person and all the people. Western individualism is a terrible mistake, even for Westerners, and it must not be imposed on other people. That imposition and its kin are responsible for all the well-meaning but disastrous attempts of white society to control the Aboriginal people. Aboriginal people don’t do individualism – or when they do, their world falls apart (as do white people’s worlds, only they don’t know it). Their unity is complex, multi-levelled, but not hierarchical or authoritarian. White fellers would do well to learn about it and try to emulate it.
I used to say that the White-bellied Sea-eagle is my totem, but now I would like to say that she is my Dreaming. But I cannot say it, because it wouldn’t be true. I got no Dreaming. I know there has been a special relationship for me with the White-bellied sea-eagles; whenever I used to go to the coast, especially the far South Coast of NSW which I love and where I feel I belong. “Used to be”: I suspect that it has got lost in recent years, since moving away from that part of the world in late 2004, and then coming to Western Australia in 2009. There are not as many White-bellied Sea eagles in the west, and one is more likely to spot an Osprey than a Sea-eagle. When I do, there is the same familiar leap in the throat, the hope that is undefined but no less for that. When we go east we see the Eagles sometimes, but we’re more likely to see the great Wedgies than their slightly smaller Sea-eagle cousins.
I got no Dreaming, and I lament. It’s not the Sea-eagles as such – it would be good, wonderful, to begin to experience Sea-eagle Dreaming for real, but that is not the loss I lament. After all, when I want to visit Sea-eagles, I know where to look. But the Dreaming is not like going to the Zoo. It is the identity-loss, the rootlessness, not having the relationship with Land and Country. Or maybe that’s the same thing, after all? If I had my Dreaming I might know. Can anyone teach me to have my Dreaming? Anyone?


[1]The title draws on the celebrated book White Man Got No Dreaming, Canberra: ANU Press 1979, essays 1938-1973 by W.H. Stanner. I read some of this book soon after publication, and the title stayed with me; as it evidently did for others. Sculptor Michael Rakowitz drew on the expertise and collaboration of several indigenous people for his 2008 installation of the same title, for the 16thSydney Biennale.
This brilliantly brings together Aboriginal hopes and dreams in “The Block,” Redfern NSW; see http://www.michaelrakowitz.com/white-man-got-no-dreaming/(accessed 11/10/2016).
[2]I tried to find the Dhurga or Thaua word for the Sea-eagle online, and although there is a beautiful little book listing many of the words – thanks to a project of Tathra Public School, aiming to preserve this pair of languages which have been officially described as “extinct” – I don’t have access to the book, and could only find this one phrase in a pamphlet for Booderee National Park in Jervis Bay, where the walk is named for the Sea-eagle’s home camp.
[3]Eugene Stockton, The Aboriginal Gift: Spirituality for a Nation, Lawson NSW: Blue Mountain Education & Research Trust, rev. ed. 2015 (1995).
[4]The word “totem” is correctly used for the relationship one North American tribe, the Ojibwa, have with their sacred creatures. It has been used for a long time by anthropologists for similar relationships in other cultures, but many Australians think it inappropriately stereotypes the many ways in which those relationships work. I agree, so I have stopped using the word “totem” in that context.
[5]“Dreaming” not “Dreamtime” as if it had stopped, or happened a long time ago. Time in Aboriginal philosophy doesn’t work like that.