The question has been whether any modernist institutions can survive the transition to a post-postmodern world. Eighteenth and nineteenth century concepts like universities, sovereign parliaments, large hospitals, institutional churches, government-owned defence and police forces, are all founded on the same principles: the common good, the rule of law, democratic governance at some level, recognition of the ideal of society as a whole; and expressed in different ways.
Today all these institutions are under attack, some people see them as "the enemy," and while lip-service is still given to the idea of democracy, people who support it have subtly redefined it, and more and more people reject it, either explicitly or implicitly.
We like to trace democracy back to Athens, but that's a myth, or at least a gross exaggeration. The vote was very limited both in scope and in terms of the electorate. Real democracy, like "real" Communism, has never actually been achieved. The closer a system comes to it, the more short-lived it is. It's a recent, fragile phenomenon, and it needs much more protection than modern democracies give it. It is subject to corruption in most places in the world, and there is still nowhere that has truly universal franchise. Some come closer that others - it is worth noting that today is the centenary of women being granted the vote (in a limited edition) in Britain, while women's franchise only goes back to 1902 in Australia. Australia's own story of limited franchise is a sorry tale.
We ignore threats to democracy at our peril. It's not a perfect system - as Churchill famously said, it's the worst of all possible systems of government, except for all the other sorts. Its weaknesses are evident daily in the US soap opera where idiocy seems to reign supreme, but they are there in every country that professes it. Australia, UK, France, Germany all suffer from fracture and loss of the old conventions of government and many democracies are increasingly ungovernable: witness the beautiful country of South Africa, for a century beset by insoluble racial issues, a small hiatus with the miraculous era of Mandela, now under threat again with Zuma unable to deliver the annual Presidential address. Democracy has been resilient, has endured Nazism, Fascism, state "Communism" and many kinds of personal dictatorship and survived, even recovered and been restored. But the context has changed, especially in the western democracies.
The unthinkable is here. Postmodern chaos is upon us, and with the inevitable retreat to fundamentalisms of various kinds, tribalisms of various kinds. There is no orderly system is these "-isms," and no limit to their proliferation. The pushback is invariably authoritarian, and that will increase.
I'm a conservative regarding social change. I believe change should be gradual, step by measured step. For that to happen, those with power and authority need to be wise as serpents, gentle as doves. And those qualities are in desperately short supply. The question is not, can we save democracy? but, with what can we replace it during the time that is coming, indeed is now here, of postmodern nihilism?
The postmodern era is, when all is said and done, merely transitional. It has no substance of its own, despite - or I should say proven by - valiant efforts of artists, architects, musicians, philosophers, and even some theologians to bring the era into mass culture. It will make way for some brave new world which only prophets and SF writers claim to see; I cannot. That brave new world is what we need to transition into, preferably without a nuclear holocaust.
The peaceable teaching of Jesus is needed more than ever before.

No comments:
Post a Comment